16. When is enough enough? Read Clinic in PS Jan 1990, pg 37.

Answer:
The reference is a chapter by Jeffrey Marsh from Washington University that condenses his experience over 11 years on 250 patients with secondary cleft surgery.  While doing nothing is not an option for the initial cleft repair, doing nothing further should be an integral part of the discussion for secondary cleft surgery.  The objectives of secondary cleft surgery should be maximum physical and psychological benefit for the patient with minimum disruption for both the patient and the family. Impaired physical function, such as speech or mastication, usually is considered a relative absolute indication. Marsh performs secondary lip and nose revision at three periods: 1) 5-6 years of age before the child enters first grade, 2) the summer between primary-secondary or junior-senior high school change, and 3) when there are significant psychosocial problems.  He stresses the evaluation should not be whether the lip or nose is normal but whether the lip or nose concern the child or attract the attention of peers. Interventions should cease when the patient is well integrated into society without limiting physical or functional sequelae of the cleft anomaly.

 BACK TO CORE CURRICULUM TOPICS PAGE